66
Table 2:
Soil lead concentrations in shooting and control areas in the UK
Gunshot source
Soil lead (mg/kg)
(average of 72 mg/kg in principal English topsoil)
Reference
Shooting Site
Control Site
Game shooting wood and
pheasant rearing area
160 (wood)
68 (field)
60 (wood)
44 (field)
Sneddon
et al.
(2009)
Clay pigeon shoot (100-175 m
from stands)
Mean of 3,038
Max. of 8,172
72
Clements (1997)
Clay pigeon fall out zone on
acid peat bog
Mean of 306
Max. of 15,700
67
White Young Green Environmental
(2006)
Clay pigeon shoot for 20 years
(80-100 m from stands)
5,000 to 10,600
-
Mellor and McCartney (1994)
executive summary
1
. Adriano (1986) provides comprehensive
information on the biogeochemistry and bioavailability of lead
in the terrestrial environment.
In areas of lead ammunition deposition, soil lead concentrations
can be extremely elevated,
e.g.
from a few to hundreds of times
higher than in control soils; some examples from the UK are
given in Table 2. The figures here can be compared with average
soil lead concentration of 72 mg/kg in principal English topsoil
(with English soils in the principal domain, covering 94% of the
area of England, having ‘Normal Background Concentrations’
of up to 180 mg/kg - British Geological Survey, see Ander
et al.
2013). A limited number of studies is available either measuring
lead in water from sites contaminated with lead, or lead in biota
exposed to water contaminated by lead from ammunition (
e.g.
Heier
et al.
2009, Stromseng
et al.
2009). These provide evidence
that in some areas where shooting occurs regularly and/or at
high intensity, and in and possibly close to the gunshot fallout
areas, water lead concentrations can be elevated above those at
control sites. The extent to which such contamination is likely to
affect sites downstream of shooting areas is unknown, but the
likelihood of broader watershed contamination appears low,
and it seems likely that the majority of the water contamination
will be relatively local.
PATHWAYS OF EXPOSURE TO LEAD
FROM AMMUNITION
DIRECT INGESTION OF AMMUNITION-DERIVED LEAD
BY WILD BIRDS (EXPOSURE ROUTE 1)
The first published record of a bird poisoned following lead
gunshot ingestion in the UK was for a pheasant, 139 years ago
(Calvert 1876). Recognition of the direct ingestion of spent
gunshot and subsequent mortality from lead poisoning in
wildfowl and a range of other birds, primarily other waterbirds
and terrestrial birds such as Galliformes, grew throughout the
last century. This pathway of ingestion of lead gunshot has been
extensively documented and reviewed (
e.g.
for global studies
see Bellrose 1959, Franson and Pain 2011, and papers in Pain
1992 and Watson
et al.
2009; for the UK see Olney 1960, 1968,
Owen and Cadbury 1975, Thomas 1975, Thomas 1982, Brown
et al.
1992, Thomas
et al.
2009, Parslow
et al.
1982, Mudge 1983,
Street 1983, Spray andMilne 1988, Butler 2005, Butler
et al.
2005,
Potts 2005, O’Connell
et al.
2008, Newth
et al.
2012). Gunshot
ingestion levels by wildfowl fromUK studies and terrestrial birds
from the UK and elsewhere are summarised in Tables 3 and 4
respectively.
Mateo (2009) provided a summary of historic prevalence of
lead gunshot ingestion in 19 species of wildfowl from Europe
including the UK (15 of which are species of swans, geese and
ducks from northern Europe). Levels of gunshot ingestion
varied among sites and species with an overall combined level
Deborah J. Pain, Ruth Cromie & Rhys E. Green
1
Available online (see
http://www.nssf.org/ranges/rangeresources/library/detail.cfm?filename=facility_mngmnt/environment/executive_summary.htm&CAT=
Facility%20Management
)